Writers and publishers: do not do this to your readers!

I just finished a book that had what I’d have to say is the worst ending of all time. I know that’s a big call, but bear with me and I’m sure you’ll agree. Now, normally I wouldn’t name and shame the book, but in this case I don’t actually blame the author. I’d be surprised if the crime against readers that is the ending of this book was her idea.

Red Riding Hood

Redeeming feature: the cover is lovely

The book is “Red Riding Hood” by Sarah Blakley-Cartwright.

I knew there was a movie based on the book—there’s a little fake sticker on the front that says “Now a major motion picture”. What I didn’t know when I bought it was that the book was actually written after the screenplay; they got Blakley-Cartwright in to write the novelisation. That’s why she has joint billing on the front of the book—the other guy is the screenplay writer. A lot of the oddities in the storytelling style (the omniscient third person narrator; the choppy, short scenes) clearly fall out of this process.

But the worst thing by far—which took the book from being an interesting horror/mystery to being an abomination—is that the publishers have printed the book without the last chapter.

I don’t just mean that the last chapter sucks or the story doesn’t finish. I mean that the final chapter of the book has actually been excised from the paperback. When you get to where it should be a web address refers you to the movie’s website, where the missing chapter is available as “bonus material”.

Don’t get me started on the idea of labeling the critical part of the novel I spent money on as a “bonus”!

Apparently the novel came out before the movie, and someone was worried that it would spoil the movie. Or decided that if people could read the ending of the book (and find out who the “Wolf” was, which was the mystery element) they wouldn’t want to see the movie. Never mind the fact that readers across the world have been managing to read books before movies for decades. Some people actually prefer to do it that way.

So the extra chapter wasn’t actually released onto the website till after the movie came out. I can’t imagine how furious I’d be if I’d bought the book beforehand and had to wait. I am frustrated enough as it is!

Withholding the end of a book from the readers isn’t a clever marketing strategy or a way to build hype. It’s insulting, and deprives readers of something they’ve (probably) paid good money for. I’m glad I bought this book secondhand. I feel less ripped off.

The other thing to consider is that a lot of book readers actually like to keep books they love on their shelves, to reread them or as a collector’s item. I’m one of those—I have shelves filled with books that I love. I would have kept this book (like I said, it’s not bad, and the cover is pretty), except it’s incomplete. What am I meant to do? Print the ten extra pages and stick them in the back? Yeah, that’s not going to happen…

I know I’m getting my ranty pants on here, but I felt extremely ripped off when I finished this book. I lay up past midnight fuming about it. (I know, I need to take a chill pill.) And I hear ranting is what blogs are all about!

I think the main lesson for writers (and publishers) is not to promise things you aren’t going to deliver in your book. If you’ve got a meta-plot arc that runs over the course of several books, that’s okay, but you’ve got to give a reader some closure at the end of your novel if you don’t want them throwing the book across the room.

Now I’m going to take a deep breath and move on. Thanks for letting me rant.

Advertisements

14 Comments on “Writers and publishers: do not do this to your readers!”

  1. inklingkitty says:

    I am at a loss for words

  2. LyudmylaM says:

    That is quite outrageous. I always try to be tactful with my reviews, so when I saw the title of this post, I was doubting your objectivity. I’m a believer now! What you are describing is unacceptable.

    • Yeah, I’ve never named and shamed a book on this blog before. I probably never will again – but given the book (if it had been intact) wasn’t that bad, I thought this was a special case!

  3. Unbelievable! And absolutely unacceptable.

  4. Wow, that’s just…wrong on so many levels. I’m curious to find out what you think of the movie, if you watch it. (I didn’t know there was a book.) It was okay – didn’t like the ending. But the soundtrack is one of my FAVORITE writing albums. I’m just sayin’.

  5. Danielle says:

    That is the most ridiculous thing I have ever heard!! Like what about all the books that are optioned for movies, should all reprints then have the last chapter missing so the movie isn’t spoiled?? What a load of poop. I’m not surprised you were annoyed. Ugh, I’ve already ranted this morning about Hollywood interfering in books, now I’m on a roll! lol x

  6. Stacey Nash says:

    OMG. That is disgusting. I wonder how many readers it has the opposite of the desired effect on. How many don’t watch the movie out of anger.

  7. Veronica says:

    Personally, I was MOST horrified after seeing the name Leonardo DiCaprio on the credits as Producer. (And yes, I do realize I’m shaming myself publicly by admitting that I saw the movie. In the theater, no less.)

    What can I say? I’ve got a weakness for awesomely bad movies.

    Fortunately, that weakness does not extend to books. And now, after reading this post I’m doubly glad I didn’t know about the book. Phew! Close call.

  8. K. A. Last says:

    I actually bought this before the movie came out, because I wanted to read it before I saw the movie (as I always do) and it has a pretty cover. When I got to the end I had a huge WTF moment. I was like, so who’s the wolf? Why are you keeping this information from me? I still went and saw the movie, which I thought was ok, but not amazing. I have to agree with you though. I felt pretty ripped off, too, and I paid full price for this book.

  9. pippajay says:

    That is SHOCKING! O.o


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s